The SOE09401 report rewards one thing above all: applying four frameworks to the case evidence, not describing the frameworks. Markers have said as much in the brief itself, which tells you to spend little time on concepts and to stay inside the two cases. If your draft explains PESTLE for 200 words before touching the pharmaceutical industry, it is already losing marks. This guide shows how to plan the 4,000 words, what each section needs, and where students most often slip.
Working on a case-based strategy report and unsure how to split the marks? Our team can review your brief and outline.
What the assessment is really asking
On the surface, the task is four analyses: PESTLE, Five Forces, generic strategies and the Ansoff matrix. Underneath, it is one argument about strategy in a global setting. The first two sections look at the global pharmaceutical industry, a case about reputation, regulation and profit. The last two look at Mars and Nestlé moving into veterinary clinics, a case about growth. Your report should read as a connected story: what the environment allows, how attractive the industry is, how each company competes, and where each should grow next.
You can read the original SOE09401 case study question for the full wording. Three constraints matter most. Analysis must rest on case information. You must not go past the case end date. And outside industry or company sources are off limits, so your credible references are mainly the textbook and the original framework papers.
The format is also specific: executive summary, contents page, headings, and tables or figures, but no bullet points in the report itself. Presentation carries 10%, which is easy to lose through sloppy formatting.
Word and mark split
Allocate words in proportion to marks, then protect the heavier sections when you run over. The table below shows a sensible plan for 4,000 words, which the brief allows to vary by 10%.
| Section | Focus | Marks | Suggested words |
|---|---|---|---|
| Question 1 | PESTLE of the pharmaceutical industry | 15% | About 800 |
| Question 2 | Five Forces and industry attractiveness | 25% | About 1,000 |
| Question 3 | Generic strategies for Mars and Nestlé | 25% | About 1,000 |
| Question 4 | Ansoff direction and recommendations | 25% | About 1,000 |
| Presentation | Executive summary, contents, headings, visuals | 10% | Formatting, plus a short summary |
Notice that PESTLE has the lowest weighting and the lowest word count. Students often write 1,200 words here because it is the easiest section, then rush the three 25% questions. Resist that.
A step plan you can follow
- Read both cases once for the story, without highlighting anything.
- Read them again and tag evidence under the headings political, economic, social, technological, legal and environmental, then under the five forces.
- For Mars and Nestlé, note separately what each company did, why, and what the case says about the result.
- Write a one-line verdict for each of the four questions before drafting any prose.
- Draft the main sections in order, keeping to the word targets.
- Write the executive summary last, from your verdicts.
- Build the contents page and check that every table and figure has a number and a title.
- Cut anything that explains a framework instead of using it, then check the word count.
Section-by-section guidance
Question 1: PESTLE of the pharmaceutical industry
A table is acceptable and efficient, but a table alone is not analysis. Under each factor, give a case-based point and a consequence for the industry. Then add a paragraph ranking the two or three factors that matter most, and explain why. The ranking is what separates a good answer from a list. Keep the section closed: it should end by pointing forward to industry structure.
Question 2: Five Forces and attractiveness
The question is about attractiveness, so you need a verdict. Rate each force as low, moderate or high, justify it with case evidence, and then weigh the forces against each other. A strong industry can still be unattractive if one force, such as buyer power, dominates. Be honest where the case gives thin evidence. Saying that the case offers little on supplier power and treating it cautiously is better than inventing detail.
Question 3: Generic strategies for Mars and Nestlé
Do not just stamp “differentiation” on each company. Show where the evidence points, check for a hybrid, and compare the two firms directly. A short comparison table works well. Then ask whether the generic choice suits the veterinary setting, where trust and clinical quality matter as much as price. That link back to the clinics is where the marks sit.
Question 4: Ansoff and recommendations
Classify the move into veterinary clinics on the matrix and defend your choice. A pet-care company serving pet owners with a new service could be read as product development or as diversification, depending on how related you judge the business to be. Either answer can score if the reasoning is clear. Then give recommendations that follow from your earlier findings, each with a stated trade-off. For a sense of how a finished extract is laid out, see our SOE09401 sample extract, which is for reference only.
Using the cases without overreaching
The two cases are different in kind, and your evidence handling should reflect that. The pharmaceutical case is broad and contested, so it gives you plenty of material for PESTLE and Five Forces, and your task is selection. The Mars and Nestlé case is narrower, so each fact has to do more work. Write the case page or section next to each point in your notes as you go. When you later need to defend a claim, you will know exactly where it came from, and you will spot quickly any point that relied on something you half-remembered from outside the case.
It also helps to decide early how you will signal evidence in the text. APA 7 asks for the textbook citation, and a short phrase such as “the case describes” keeps the link to the material visible without cluttering the paragraph. Consistency matters more than style here.
Common mistakes
Most lost marks come from a short list of habits.
- Spending the opening of each section defining the framework.
- Bringing in outside facts about the companies, which the brief forbids.
- Using bullet points inside the report body.
- Describing forces or factors without saying which matter most.
- Treating Mars and Nestlé as identical, when the question asks for each.
- Recommendations that do not connect to any earlier finding.
- Skipping figure numbers, captions or the contents page.
Want your structure, tables and executive summary checked before you submit? See how we support formal reports.
Timing your drafting
Give the three 25% sections most of your drafting time, and leave a full day for editing. A report of this size usually improves most in the final pass, when you cut repetition, tighten verdict sentences and make the tables match the text. If a table says buyer power is high, the paragraph beneath must say so too, for the same reason. Mismatches like that are easy for a marker to spot and hard for you to see after hours of writing.
Mark-maximising checklist
- Each question has a clear verdict in its final paragraph.
- Every claim traces back to the case, not to outside reading.
- Frameworks are applied, never lectured on.
- Word counts sit within about 10% of 4,000 overall.
- Executive summary reflects the final conclusions.
- Contents page, headings, tables and figures are numbered and consistent.
- No bullet points appear in the report body.
- APA 7 in-text citations match the reference list, with at least five credible references.
If the wider module is a challenge, our management assignment help services cover strategy and related coursework.
FAQs
How long should the executive summary be?
Keep it to roughly one page, or whatever your module guidance sets. It should state the four main conclusions and the recommendation, and it should be written after the rest of the report.
Can I use bullet points in tables?
The brief rules out bullet points in the report, so use short phrases or sentences inside table cells and keep full prose beneath each table.
Do I need to define PESTLE and the other frameworks?
No. A single clause is enough. Marks go to applying each framework to the case evidence, so definitions use up words you need for analysis.
Can I use sources beyond the textbook?
The brief says analysis must be based on case information and that outside industry or company sources should not be used. Use the textbook and the original framework papers for concepts, and confirm anything else with your tutor.
What counts as going beyond the case end date?
Any event, figure or development that happened after the period the case covers. If you are unsure whether a fact belongs in the case, leave it out.
How should I reference the case itself?
Cite the textbook edition in APA 7, using the authors, year, edition and publisher, and point to the relevant case within the text. Check your module handbook for the exact local convention.
If you would like a second pair of eyes on your outline before you start writing, you can submit your assignment brief here.