The brief this answer responds to
For information and reference only – not to be submitted as your own work. This extract shows how a strong SOE09401 case study report is built. It does not reproduce the case text, so every point marked illustrative must be replaced with evidence from your own copy of the cases. This extract responds to the […]
For information and reference only – not to be submitted as your own work. This extract shows how a strong SOE09401 case study report is built. It does not reproduce the case text, so every point marked illustrative must be replaced with evidence from your own copy of the cases.
This extract responds to the SOE09401 Strategic Management in a Global Context case study question, a 4,000-word report built on two cases from Exploring Strategy: the global pharmaceutical industry, and Mars’ and Nestlé’s diversification into veterinary clinics. Because the brief limits you to case information and forbids outside industry or company sources, the extract concentrates on structure and reasoning rather than on facts. If you want the marking logic behind it first, read our guide to approaching the SOE09401 report.
Planning table
| Section | Case | Framework | Target words | Weighting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Executive summary and contents | Both | None | Outside the count where permitted | Presentation (10%) |
| 1. External environment | Pharmaceutical industry | PESTLE | About 800 | 15% |
| 2. Industry attractiveness | Pharmaceutical industry | Five Forces | About 1,000 | 25% |
| 3. Competitive strategy | Mars and Nestlé | Generic strategies | About 1,000 | 25% |
| 4. Growth direction and recommendations | Mars and Nestlé | Ansoff matrix | About 1,000 | 25% |
Have a different case pair or a tighter word limit? Send us your brief and we will map the sections and marks for you.
Executive summary (extract)
This report assesses the external environment and competitive structure of the global pharmaceutical industry, then evaluates the strategies of Mars and Nestlé as each moved into veterinary clinics. The pharmaceutical analysis concludes that the industry is attractive to established players but increasingly constrained by regulation, pricing pressure and public scrutiny. The diversification analysis concludes that veterinary care offers both firms a defensible position, provided integration costs are controlled. The report recommends a staged, partnership-led expansion rather than rapid acquisition (illustrative conclusion – align with your own evidence).
1. PESTLE analysis of the global pharmaceutical industry (extract)
A PESTLE table earns marks only when each factor is tied to an effect on the industry. The brief asks you to spend little time explaining the framework, so one sentence of justification is enough before the table.
| Factor | Case evidence to cite | Impact on the industry |
|---|---|---|
| Political | The case’s evidence on government pricing and procurement (illustrative – replace with your case evidence) | Limits the price a firm can charge and slows market entry |
| Economic | The case’s evidence on research costs and healthcare spending (illustrative) | High fixed costs favour large firms |
| Social | The case’s evidence on public attitudes toward the industry (illustrative) | Reputation shapes licence to operate |
| Technological | The case’s evidence on drug discovery and data (illustrative) | Raises the cost of staying competitive |
| Legal | The case’s evidence on patents and regulation (illustrative) | Patent expiry exposes revenue to generics |
| Environmental | The case’s evidence on manufacturing and waste (illustrative) | Adds compliance cost and reputational risk |
After the table, rank the factors. A report that says legal and social pressures matter most, and explains why, scores higher than one that gives six equal paragraphs. Close the section with a single sentence that tells the reader what the environment means for the next section: an industry with high barriers but heavy scrutiny.
2. Porter’s Five Forces: industry attractiveness (extract)
The question is whether the industry is attractive, not whether the forces exist. Give each force a rating and a reason, then reach a verdict. Porter’s framework (Porter, 2008) treats industry profitability as the result of the combined strength of all five forces, so your conclusion has to weigh them against each other.
| Force | Illustrative rating | Reasoning to build from your case |
|---|---|---|
| Threat of new entrants | Low | Argue from research cost, regulatory approval and patents, using the case’s evidence |
| Bargaining power of buyers | High | Argue from the concentration of payers and public purchasers described in the case |
| Bargaining power of suppliers | Low to moderate | Test whether the case shows any dependence on specialist inputs |
| Threat of substitutes | Moderate | Consider generics and alternative treatments, only if the case supports it |
| Rivalry | Moderate to high | Consider competition on innovation rather than price, if the case supports it |
The ratings above are illustrative and exist to show the format. Your own ratings must follow the case. A good verdict paragraph reads something like this: the industry remains attractive for firms with strong patent portfolios, but buyer power and regulation compress margins for everyone else (illustrative wording). That is a judgement, and it is what the 25% weighting rewards.
3. Generic strategies for Mars and Nestlé (extract)
Porter’s generic strategies (Porter, 1980, 1985) are cost leadership, differentiation and focus. Do not simply label each company. Show the evidence for the label, then say whether the strategy fits the veterinary setting. It is widely reported that Mars owns veterinary hospital brands including VCA, Banfield and BluePearl, and in Europe AniCura and Linnaeus (American Veterinary Medical Association, 2018). For Nestlé, use only what your case states about its move into clinics; do not add outside detail.
| Test | Mars | Nestlé |
|---|---|---|
| Where does the advantage come from? | Use the case’s evidence on scale, brands and clinic networks | Use the case’s evidence on its pet-care position and clinic entry |
| Cost, differentiation or focus? | State your reasoned classification | State your reasoned classification |
| Risk of being “stuck in the middle” | Test it against the case | Test it against the case |
Where the case shows a firm pursuing elements of two strategies, say so and explain the tension. Markers value an honest, evidenced “hybrid” over a forced single label.
4. Ansoff and recommendations (extract)
Ansoff’s matrix (Ansoff, 1957) crosses existing and new products with existing and new markets. A pet-food company opening clinics is selling a new service, veterinary care, to a customer group it already reaches, pet owners. The classification therefore needs care: it may sit between product development and diversification depending on how the case frames the link. State your reasoning and commit to one answer (illustrative – decide using your case).
| Option | Fit with the case | Main risk |
|---|---|---|
| Market penetration | Deepen the existing pet-care offer | Limited growth headroom |
| Product development | Add clinic services to existing customers | Capability gaps in clinical care |
| Market development | Take the model to new regions | Local regulation and professional rules |
| Diversification | Enter veterinary care as a new business | Highest risk and integration cost |
The recommendations should follow directly from the earlier sections: name two or three actions, link each to a finding, and state the trade-off. Avoid bullet points in the final report, as the brief requires full prose beneath each heading. The textbook (Johnson et al., 2023) is your main source for the framework definitions, so keep outside reading out of the report.
Notice how each section above ends on a judgement. Sections that finish with a verdict give the executive summary something to quote, and they show the marker that the frameworks are doing analytical work. Check that every table cell in your final version points to a specific item of case evidence, and that the same company is described consistently from one section to the next.
Need help turning your case notes into a structured report with an executive summary and tables?
For layout, headings and executive summaries, see our report writing help. Wider strategy and business modules are covered under management assignment help services, and you can compare the approach with our Porter’s Five Forces sample.
References
- Ansoff, H. I. (1957). Strategies for diversification. Harvard Business Review, 35(5), 113–124.
- American Veterinary Medical Association. (2018, August 1). Mars buys hospitals in Europe. JAVMA News. https://www.avma.org/News/JAVMANews/Pages/180801h.aspx
- Johnson, G., Whittington, R., Regnér, P., Angwin, D., & Scholes, K. (2023). Exploring strategy: Text and cases (13th ed.). Pearson.
- Porter, M. E. (1980). Competitive strategy: Techniques for analyzing industries and competitors. Free Press.
- Porter, M. E. (1985). Competitive advantage: Creating and sustaining superior performance. Free Press.
- Porter, M. E. (2008). The five competitive forces that shape strategy. Harvard Business Review, 86(1), 78–93.
This model answer was prepared by our editorial team in response to a real assignment brief we received. It shows one way to approach the task and is meant as a study guide, not for submission.
This page is public, so Turnitin has already seen it
Read it for structure, sourcing and depth. Submitting any part of it is caught immediately. Your own brief will differ from this one, and so should your answer.